Clayton Plan Commission — November 16: Arundel Place rebuilds approved, Neighborhood Design Guidelines adopted
The board approved renovations at 59 Arundel and a tornado-damaged rebuild at 73 Arundel, then adopted updated Neighborhood Design Guidelines with a condition on gas-lantern language.
What happened
The Clayton Plan Commission and Architectural Review Board convened on November 16, 2026, working through four agenda items: exterior alterations at 59 Arundel Place; a site-plan review and architectural review for a new house at 73 Arundel Place — a property the developer described as having been struck by a tornado in May 2025 and deemed beyond repair; and a review of updated Neighborhood Design Guidelines. All four items were approved by voice vote.
What the commission decided
- 59 Arundel Place — Architectural Review: the board approved the exterior alterations as submitted with two staff conditions: brick shall comprise at least 25% of each facade of the new detached garage, and signed and sealed plans shall be provided with the building permit submission.
- 73 Arundel Place — Site Plan Review: the board approved the site plan as submitted with the staff condition regarding the bioretention area — requiring the applicant to provide a copy of MSD plan approval and associated recording and inspection requirements prior to issuance of a building permit, and, if MSD does not require a deed restriction, the applicant shall record one with St. Louis County.
- 73 Arundel Place — Architectural Review: the board approved the new house as submitted with the condition that the one-story portion of the roof be revised to a lower slope to provide greater visual interest, as described during the meeting.
- Neighborhood Design Guidelines: the board approved the updated guidelines with the condition that the gas-lantern language be revised per the discussion, with the updated wording to be presented at the next meeting.
- Minutes: the board approved the minutes of the November 2, 2026 meeting as submitted by voice vote.
Who was there
Roll call at the opening of the meeting recorded the following members present: Steve Lichtenfeld, Helen DiFate, Jim Arsenault, Chris Brennan, Blair Kweskin, Jeff Morrisey, and Susan Buse. No absences were noted in the record.