Clayton Plan Commission — July 20: Gelateria CUP approved, Bemiston facade tabled, sign sub-district rejected, and UDC rewrite previewed
Gelateria wins CUP, Bemiston turf debate forces a table, and staff previews Clayton's residential zoning overhaul.
What happened
The Clayton Plan Commission and Architectural Review Board met on July 20, 2026, and worked through three action items before turning to a lengthy discussion session on the city's residential zoning code rewrite. The board approved a conditional use permit for a new gelateria at 42 North Central Avenue, tabled a front-facade and front-yard overhaul at 122 North Bemiston Avenue after debate over artificial turf, and declined to approve a proposed sign sub-district for the mixed-use tower at 7701 Forsyth Boulevard. Staff then presented a detailed preview of proposed changes to the residential unified development code and a new neighborhood pattern-book framework.
What the commission decided
- 42 North Central Avenue — approved a conditional use permit for a gelateria (restaurant use requiring a CUP) in a planned-unit-development mixed-use building on the east side of North Central between Maryland and Forsyth. The tenant space had not been previously occupied.
- 122 North Bemiston Avenue — the board voted to table the facade and front-yard proposal to a future date to be determined. One member cast a dissenting vote. The chair noted the applicant would be placed back on the agenda upon resubmission of information, and that the standard 60-day ARB decision timeline might not apply depending on when materials are resubmitted.
- 7701 Forsyth Boulevard — the proposed sign sub-district for the mixed-use commercial tower at the northwest corner of Hanley and Forsyth was not approved. Multiple members expressed opposition to concentrating the building's full sign allowance in a single band of large wall signs.
- Minutes from the July 6 meeting were approved as submitted.
Who was there
The transcript records the following members responding to roll call: Steve Lichtenfeld, Helen DiFate, Jim Arsenault, Blair Kweskin, Jeff Morrisey, and Susan Buse. The record does not indicate any absences.
What they debated
**42 North Central — Treycora Gelateria CUP.** The applicant, Rafael Rezende, introduced himself as co-owner of Treycora Gelateria, describing it as a small business he and his wife own with one existing location in the Ellisville/Chesterfield area. He said the business is roughly 80–85 percent driven by gelato, with acai bowls, coffee, and small sweets rounding out the menu. Board members expressed enthusiasm, with one noting the community had not had a business of that type for years.
A member asked about signage compliance, noting there appeared to be a sign sub-district already in place for the site and flagging a roof scupper near the proposed sign location. Another member raised the Green Dining Alliance as a future consideration. No substantive objections were raised and the item moved quickly to a vote.
**122 North Bemiston Avenue — facade and front-yard alterations.** The applicant's architect described a project including removal of front-yard hedges and lawn, installation of native plantings, installation of artificial turf, a new copper-roofed front porch, concrete pavers, and replacement of two windows with French doors. Staff recommended approval conditioned on removing artificial turf, calling the turf's use in a front yard uncommon and likely to have some visual impact.
The homeowner spoke to the board, explaining that the house had significant water intrusion problems and that he had spent no fewer than 200 hours addressing water-related issues in the masonry. He said the hydrangeas had been successfully transplanted to the backyard rather than removed.
Board members raised several concerns. One member cited the environmental persistence of plastic materials in turf and noted that the front yard's green-space compliance already meets or slightly exceeds Clayton's goals while the backyard falls short, meaning turf would worsen the overall property's compliance with those goals. Another member said turf remained a significant concern not just for this site but as a precedent if approved elsewhere.
A member asked staff why the project did not require site-plan review. Staff explained that facade changes, not landscaping alone, brought the scope before the board; pure landscape changes would not normally rise to the ARB level, but the combination of turf with the porch and front-facade changes did. A complete regrading of the site would trigger additional stormwater review, but the proposed grade changes were relatively low. Members also asked for more detail on the native plantings — what species and where they would be placed — before they could feel comfortable approving the project.
The chair noted that while staff had recommended approval without turf, the board preferred to table the item for resubmission with additional detail. The motion to table passed with one dissenting vote.
**7701 Forsyth — sign sub-district.** The applicant's representative explained that the Missouri Athletic Club's pending tenancy in the building had triggered the request, as the building was already at its sign allowance and the MAC wanted exterior visibility. The proposal would prioritize more wall signs in exchange for reduced window signage and would not create any non-conformities.
Several members were skeptical. One said that concentrating all sign allowance in one band all the way around the building would make it look like a giant advertisement. Another said allowing every tenant to have individual signs on a high-rise was 'overdone and ugly.' A third member said the sub-district felt like rewriting the sign rules for one building and that doubling the number of large hanging signs was not acceptable.
Members also debated aesthetics: one noted that the renderings showed white signs that 'stick out very prominently and really destroy the base of that building', and suggested backlit channel letters on a dark background would look better. Staff noted that sign materials and lighting are not fully controlled under the proposed sub-district as written.
Staff indicated that if the applicant wished to pursue the sub-district further, more information on materials, lighting, and aesthetics would be needed. The board did not approve the sub-district.
**Clayton 2040 residential UDC discussion.** Staff presented a wide-ranging preview of the residential zoning code rewrite flowing from the Clayton 2040 comprehensive plan. The presentation covered proposed changes to dimensional standards, use regulations, infill guidelines, floor area ratio caps, and a new neighborhood pattern-book framework to replace the current architectural guidelines.
On dimensional standards, staff described a reduced accessory garage setback to one foot for garages under 14 feet tall, with a 10-foot minimum separation from structures on adjacent properties. Staff also proposed reducing the R5 minimum lot width from 50 to 40 feet to reflect actual lot sizes in that district.
On use regulations, staff described several cleanup items, including removing a redundant R4 office allowance, removing a restaurant allowance in R6 where no restaurants exist, and reducing the parking-lot proximity limit near commercial zoning in higher-density residential districts from 500 feet to 200 feet. Staff also described clarifying the R1 use table to show pre-K and university uses as conditionally permitted rather than burying that allowance in a separate paragraph.
On infill standards, staff described new requirements for R1, R2, and R3 districts, including a finished floor height requirement (within one foot of the average of adjacent properties), a basement exposure limit, a defined half-story standard (up to 60% of the floor below), and an alternative compliance path. Staff also noted a proposal to rezone four lots in the R7 district along South Brentwood to M3, which better reflects their current development.
On floor area ratio, staff presented neighborhood-by-neighborhood analysis. For Clayton Gardens (a type B neighborhood), a proposed FAR cap of 0.5 for Clayton Gardens was described as appropriate because 81% of the homes that would exceed the cap were built after 2000, fitting the pattern of newer homes being too large. For Clavarack Park (a type A neighborhood), a proposed FAR cap of 0.3 for Clavarack Park was described as a way to reinforce the value of existing homes rather than incentivize teardown, since about 30% of lots already exceed the cap but teardown activity has been limited. Staff cautioned that FAR caps alone would not control the form of new construction and that infill standards would have more influence on how development looks from the street.
On neighborhood pattern books, staff described a plan to designate all single-family and duplex properties into four neighborhood typologies (A through D), with type D reserved exclusively for the Clayshire and Tanglewood neighborhoods due to their distinct lot orientation and massing patterns. Each typology would have a pattern book identifying character patterns for massing, height, roofs, dormers, architectural features, garages, and materials. These pattern books would replace the current architectural guidelines, which exist only as text on the city's website and are not codified.
A board member expressed appreciation for the height-setback ratio element, saying they had advocated for it previously. Staff described the next steps as completing full drafts and beginning the formal text amendment process, with the pattern books to be adopted by the ARB to replace the existing guidelines, while the base zoning changes would go through a formal ordinance amendment process.
Also at the meeting
During the open forum at the start of the meeting, one person, Rafael Rezende, was listed to speak but the chair indicated the board already knew what he was there for and moved on. No other open-forum speakers came forward.
At the close of the gelateria item, the applicant mentioned his wife had wanted to bring gelato for the board but was uncertain about the logistics; he said he would find a future opportunity to do so.
In context
**Artificial turf and front-yard standards.** The ARB has a history of scrutinizing non-traditional front-yard materials. Prior meeting records show the board has consistently applied Section 405.1900 of the Zoning Regulations to front-yard features in single-family districts, requiring ARB approval before installation of fences and similar elements. A December 2018 minutes entry and a July 2019 minutes entry both reflect that framework. At the July 20 meeting, a board member raised the broader concern that approving turf could set a precedent as the city works to restore green cover following tornado damage.
**Residential UDC rewrite timeline.** The July 20 presentation is part of a multi-year effort. A March 2026 minutes entry records a discussion of 2026 objectives including neighborhood standards, lot sizes and setbacks, and infill standards. The July 20 session moved that work forward by presenting draft structural changes and FAR analysis, with staff indicating full red-line drafts and a formal text amendment process are the next steps.
**Neighborhood pattern books.** The evolution from text-based architectural guidelines to codified pattern books has been discussed over several years. A November 2023 minutes entry records a discussion of updates to the Architectural Review Guidelines pertaining to permitted materials and approval processes. At the July 20 session, staff confirmed that the pattern books will be adopted by the ARB to replace the existing guidelines, while the base zoning changes go through a formal ordinance amendment process.
**Clayton Gardens FAR and teardown history.** The commission has grappled with oversized new construction in Clayton Gardens for years. A September 2016 minutes entry notes that properties west of Forsyth in Clayton Gardens have traditionally been developed with one-story ranch-style homes. At the July 20 meeting, staff presented data showing that 81% of Clayton Gardens homes exceeding the proposed FAR cap were built after 2000, framing the cap as a tool to stop perpetuating that pattern rather than penalizing older homes.
Public comments
For the 42 North Central gelateria item, the transcript records no audience comments or raised hands after the board's discussion.
For the 122 North Bemiston Avenue item, the homeowner Kevin Krakowski addressed the board, describing the water intrusion problems that motivated the project and expressing confidence that the applicant team could address the board's concerns. His wife Beth also spoke briefly to thank the board. The transcript does not record any other audience members speaking on this item.
The transcript does not record any audience public comment on the 7701 Forsyth sign sub-district item or on the UDC discussion session.