Clayton Plan Commission — August 3: Concordia Seminary housing approved with conditions; Café Napoli screening continued
The commission conditionally approved Concordia Seminary's Phase 1 site plan and continued the unpermitted Café Napoli screening to a future date.
What happened
The Clayton Plan Commission and Architectural Review Board met on August 3, 2026 and worked through a full agenda. The commission conditionally approved the Phase 1 site plan for new student housing at Concordia Seminary, continued the Café Napoli screening application to a future date, approved a sign modification at 7701 Forsyth, and received a second round of feedback — but took no vote — on the mixed-use redevelopment proposal at 48 South Bemiston Avenue.
What the commission decided
- 801 Seminary Place (Concordia Seminary, Phase 1 site plan): approved the site plan by voice vote, subject to staff confirmation that the three staff-recommended criteria had been met, administrative review of the stormwater remediation plan, and a requirement that the Phase 1 tree-planting deficit be resolved during building permits for subsequent phases — or within six months if construction ceases for six months or more.
- 7701 Forsyth (sign modification): approved the sign modification with staff's condition — permitting one new 20-square-foot aluminum wall sign on the Forsyth facade, with no additional window signs or blade signs to be installed along that facade.
- 7754 Forsyth (Café Napoli screening and pergola): continued the application to a date to be determined; the pergola was separately directed to be placed on the next ARB agenda to allow its building permit to proceed.
- 48 South Bemiston Avenue (mixed-use redevelopment): continued all four applications to a date to be determined, with the applicant indicating a 60-day extension waiver would be provided by Friday, August 7.
Who was there
The chair called roll at the opening of the meeting. Members recorded present were Steve Lichtenfeld, Helen DiFate, Jim Arsenault, Chris Brennan, Blair Kweskin, Jeff Morrisey, and Susan Buse. The record does not reflect any absences or late arrivals.
What they debated
The lengthiest discussion of the evening centered on the two Concordia Seminary applications — site plan review and architectural review — for what the project team is calling "The Woods 2.0," a five-phase reconstruction of student housing on the western portion of the campus.
On the site plan, staff had recommended continuation, citing three unresolved items: the need for pre- and post-construction drainage sub-area calculations, a color-coded landscape plan distinguishing removed from added trees within Phase 1, and either a revised Phase 1 tree-replacement plan or additional information justifying deferral to later phases. The commission heard staff's three recommended conditions in full before the applicant's team — which included a landscape architect, civil engineer, and architect — distributed exhibits responding to those comments at the meeting itself.
The civil engineer explained the drainage situation: the site straddles two watersheds — River De Pere to the north and Deer Creek to the south — and Phase 1 requires construction of the entire new dry detention basin sized for all five phases. The commission heard the two-watershed drainage overview before turning to runoff figures. The total runoff increase across all phases is 1.02 cubic feet per second in a 100-year, 60-minute storm event; the engineer noted that MSD's standard threshold is two CFS, though MSD is holding the project to stricter requirements. A commission member raised concern that the northern detention basin addressing drainage to Dartford Avenue is not planned until Phase 3, leaving an existing flooding problem unaddressed in the interim.
On trees, the applicant acknowledged that Phase 1 ends with a 550-caliper-inch deficit, but explained that the conditional use permit allows replacement to occur in future phases. After extended discussion about protecting the city if the project stopped before Phase 5, the commission settled on language tying the deficit to subsequent building permits, or requiring satisfaction within six months of any construction stoppage lasting six months or more.
The architectural review discussion focused on the proposed 1920s prairie-style design for the four new three-bedroom residential structures. The applicant described the building materials and design concept as masonry veneer, James Hardie fiber cement lap siding, cast stone band sills, and an asphalt-shingled hip roof. The architect of record then presented physical material samples, clarifying that the masonry is a concrete brick — full bed depth, four inches high and 16 inches long — and not clay-fired.
Several members expressed reservations. One noted that the rear facade faces Big Bend Boulevard and comprises only 35% masonry, and expressed disappointment that the buildings lack the depth and articulation of the existing campus structures. Another member said she could see the prairie-style intent in the low eaves and horizontal elements but was concerned the masonry could read as cinder block from a distance; she asked the team to ensure color variability in the concrete brick to avoid a flat appearance. The architect responded that the manufacturer's product has a natural color range and that the team would specify mixed pallets.
On the Café Napoli matter at 7754 Forsyth, the commission reviewed a request to retain a pergola and concrete planter screening installed without permits at the southeast corner of Bemiston Avenue and Forsyth Boulevard. Staff's analysis found the pergola compatible but the composite screening boards problematic — the upper 4 feet 3 inches of the barrier were found inconsistent with consumer emphasis area guidelines, and the installation may encroach into the public right-of-way.
The applicant's architect argued that the concrete planters provide security and visual benefits and do not encroach into the right-of-way, and asked that the composite boards be allowed to remain. Commission members were largely sympathetic to a low planter but critical of the upper screening; one described a "tunnel effect" from inside the patio. Another member emphasized that the screening encouraged sidewalk storage of chairs and other items, hindering pedestrians.
Staff also disclosed that the matter is pending in municipal court for noncompliance with building permit requirements, and that a judge had expressed safety concerns because the pergola had not been reviewed by the building official. In response, the commission directed that the pergola be placed on the next ARB agenda separately, so its building permit could advance, while the full application would return once the applicant had revised the height, materials, and any right-of-way encroachment issues.
At 7701 Forsyth, the commission reviewed a request for a sign modification — one new 20-square-foot aluminum wall sign on the Forsyth facade of the mixed-use tower at the northwest corner of Hanley Road and Forsyth Boulevard. Staff recommended approval with a condition barring future window or blade signs on the same facade, noting the building currently underutilizes its permitted sign area there. One member suggested swapping the Hoffman and new signs so the Hoffman sign would remain above the main entrance, but the applicant indicated the placement was the building owner's preference. Another member suggested extending the no-new-signs condition to the Hanley and north facades, but the chair noted those facades were not part of the current application.
On 48 South Bemiston Avenue, the commission received a second round of feedback on a proposed mixed-use development that would consolidate three lots at the northwest corner of Bemiston Avenue and Forsyth Boulevard. The applicant had requested that all four applications be considered for feedback only, not for a vote.
Commission members continued to press on density. One noted that the proposal would reduce the FAR from roughly 4.2 to 0.63, characterizing the result as a suburban rather than urban plan inconsistent with the city's comprehensive plan goal of maximizing lot coverage and density. Multiple members reiterated the view that development should focus on the Sterling Bank parcel alone rather than demolishing adjacent buildings to create a large surface plaza. One member acknowledged the code-deficiency argument for the existing buildings but said that did not justify replacing them with a surface parking lot.
Also at the meeting
The chair noted that item number 2 on the new business agenda had been stricken before the meeting began.
The commission approved the July 20 minutes without changes.
No one came forward during the open forum period at the start of the meeting.
The commission took a brief recess between the Bemiston item and new business.
In context
The 48 South Bemiston Avenue proposal has now been before the commission at two consecutive meetings without a vote. The applications were first considered on July 6, 2026, when staff noted the building as proposed would not meet the consumer emphasis area requirement and that the applicant was seeking alternative compliance. At the August 3 meeting, a commission member again concluded that the alternative compliance narrative does not meet the bar for that relief.
The commission's framework for evaluating alternative compliance has been a recurring topic across meetings. As far back as July 2022, members discussed the standard requiring an applicant to show the code's intent is met through a different means than what the code literally requires. In October 2025, staff presented an overview of alternative compliance in urban design districts, noting it had been added as a formal mechanism for the commission to consider.
The Concordia Seminary project arrived at the August 3 meeting with a city council-approved conditional use permit already in place. Staff noted that the council approved that CUP in May 2026, establishing the framework for all five phases of campus redevelopment.
Public comments
No members of the public came forward during the open forum at the start of the meeting. On the Concordia Seminary drainage item, a commission member asked whether any nearby residents had responded to the required notice; the civil engineer stated that no residents had reached out, though she acknowledged that Tuscany Park to the south has experienced flooding issues.